1 · Front parlor
Judge Johnston
Public story: A careful host determined to preserve civility. He says the ledger was in his study before dinner.
Private clue: He invited the banker to discuss a disputed property entry, not money. He heard an unfamiliar tune from the music room at 8:15.
2 · Dining room
Mrs. Johnston
Public story: A gracious hostess who refuses to let fear ruin her table.
Private clue: She overheard talk of the bank route and quietly moved the ledger. She admits it only when shown the torn blue ribbon.
3 · Music room
Frank James
Public story: The quieter brother, observant and unexpectedly comfortable at the piano.
Private clue: He played a hymn to calm the room. The route map under the bench is a discarded decoy, not a final plan.
4 · Library
Jesse James
Public story: Restless, charming, and irritated that dinner has delayed the road.
Private clue: He considered the bank only as rumor; the warm welcome and visible town activity made the idea foolish. He never entered the study.
5 · Study
Silas Reed, banker
Public story: A nervous banker who insists the missing ledger proves a robbery plot.
Private clue: He brought a copied route map to impress the Judge, then lost it. His panic created the rumor he feared.
6 · Kitchen
Eliza Mercer, cook
Public story: She sees every tray, door, and hurried whisper.
Private clue: Mrs. Johnston entered the pantry carrying a large book wrapped in a blue cloth. Eliza protected her confidence.
7 · Veranda
Dr. Ada Bell, traveler
Public story: A physician delayed by weather who watches people more closely than objects.
Private clue: At the time of the disappearance, Jesse was on the veranda and Frank was at the piano. The banker was searching his own coat for the map.
8 · Carriage house
Thomas Clay, stable keeper
Public story: He knows which horses were ready and which guests planned to leave.
Private clue: No horse was prepared for a rapid bank escape. He found the other half of the blue ribbon beside the pantry door.